6-inch 3-Layer Round Cake
$125Serves a small gathering. Signature design style.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Custom orders are available for Monday–Friday pickup, subject to availability and weekly capacity.
By Request
Custom Orders
Celebration cakes, cupcake letter and number cakes, cinnamon rolls, cookies and more — made in Sugar Mama's signature style. Browse our approved Custom Order Menu below, then place your order on Bakesy.
Order Custom on Bakesy
Bakesy handles the full order: product, flavor, size, quantity, personalization, pickup date, submission and payment.
How it works
1 · Browse the menu
Look through our approved Custom Order Menu, prices and flavors right here.
2 · Order on Bakesy
Tap “Order Custom on Bakesy” to head straight to our ordering page.
3 · Bakesy does the rest
Choose your product, flavor, size, options and pickup date, then pay — all on Bakesy.
This month's specialty flavor
September / Fall — Brown Butter Spice Cake with Apple Pie Filling and Salted Caramel Swiss Meringue. One specialty flavor is offered each month.
Custom Order Menu
Everything we offer for custom orders is listed here. If it isn't listed, we don't offer it.
Round Cakes
Three-layer round cakes in Sugar Mama's signature design style. Add a custom cake topper and simple milk or white chocolate lettering (Happy Birthday, Congratulations, Happy Anniversary, Baby Shower or another short approved message).
8-inch 3-Layer Round Cake
$165Our celebration size. Signature design style.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Cupcakes
12 regular cupcakes = 1 flavor · 24 = up to 2 flavors (12 each) · 36 = up to 3 flavors (12 each). 18 minis = 1 flavor · 36 = up to 2 flavors (18 each) · 54 = up to 3 flavors (18 each).
Regular Cupcakes
12 for $48Sold in sets of 12. One flavor per dozen.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Mini Cupcakes
18 for $36Sold in sets of 18. One flavor per set.
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Cupcake Cakes · Letter & Number Cakes
Letter Cakes (A–Z) and Number Cakes (0–9) are made entirely from cupcakes arranged into your chosen letter or number in Sugar Mama's signature design style. They are not cut cakes, sheet cakes, sculpted cakes or traditional cake layers.
Mini Cupcake Cake
$65Built from 24 mini cupcakes. Choose a letter (A–Z) or number (0–9).
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Regular Cupcake Cake
$85Built from 18 regular-size cupcakes. Choose a letter (A–Z) or number (0–9).
Vanilla · Chocolate · Strawberry · Lemon · Coconut · Oreo · Chocolate Chip · Funfetti · Red Velvet · Biscoff · Monthly specialty
Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls
Oversized, soft and gooey — baked fresh for your pickup day.
Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls
6 for $36 · 9 for $54 · 12 for $72Choose your quantity on Bakesy.
Plain · Apple Pie · Brown Butter · Maple Bacon · Blueberry Yuzu Lemon
Cookies
Thick, bakery-style cookies in our house flavors plus seasonal rotations.
Cookies
6 for $27 · 12 for $52Seasonal flavors rotate — Brown Butter Maple Chai for Fall.
Brown Butter · Brown Butter Toffee · Sugar Cookie · Double Chocolate · Lemon Sugar Cookie · Cookies & Cream · Chocolate Pistachio · Seasonal
Cream Pie Cookies
6 for $36 · 12 for $65Filled cream pie style cookies.
Gingerbread · Brown Butter · Apple Pie · Maple Brown Sugar · Carrot Cake Biscoff · Chocolate Hazelnut · Brown Sugar Lavender Blueberry
Brownies, Bars & Treats
Perfect for trays, gifting and dessert tables.
Brownies
6 for $30 · 12 for $60Fudgy and rich.
Plain Brown Butter · S'mores · Cookies & Cream · Turtle Toffee · White Chocolate Raspberry
Dessert Bars
6 for $30 · 12 for $60Soft, buttery bars.
Strawberry Shortcake · Blondies · Lemon Lavender Blueberry
Rice Krispie Treats
6 for $30 · 12 for $60Extra thick and chewy.
Brown Butter · Vanilla Bean · Biscoff · S'mores
Japanese Milk Bread
Pillowy, hand-shaped loaves baked to order.
Japanese Milk Bread
$15 per loafSold by the loaf.
Plain · Garlic Herb · Cinnamon Roll · Jalapeño Cheddar
Custom order does not mean completely customizable
You may only order the products, flavors, sizes, quantities and approved personalization listed on our Custom Order Menu. If something is not listed, we do not offer it as a custom order. A flavor appearing on a past weekly menu does not make it available for custom ordering — seasonal and whimsical flavors keep rotating through our weekly menu drops.
What we offer
- Products, sizes and quantities listed above
- Listed flavors, plus the current monthly specialty flavor
- A custom cake topper
- Simple milk or white chocolate lettering — Happy Birthday, Congratulations, Happy Anniversary, Baby Shower or another short approved message
- Letters A–Z and numbers 0–9 as cupcake cakes
What we don't offer
- Character cakes or sculpted cakes
- Fondant designs
- Recreations of outside cake designs
- Custom recipes, unlisted flavors or unlisted fillings
- Frosting modifications
- Major design modifications
- Traditional cake layers shaped like letters or numbers
Pickup availability
Custom orders are available for Monday–Friday pickup, subject to availability and weekly capacity. Pickup dates are chosen on Bakesy when you place your order.
Ready to order?
Bakesy walks you through product, flavor, size, quantity, personalization, pickup date and payment.